CProgol Version 4.4 |- yes [:- set(verbose,2)? - Time taken 0.00s] |- [:- set(h,10000)? - Time taken 0.00s] [:- set(r,1000000)? - Time taken 0.00s] [:- set(i,5)? - Time taken 0.00s] [:- set(c,5)? - Time taken 0.00s] [:- modeh(100,play([+int,+int,+int]))? - Time taken 0.00s] [:- modeh(100,play([+int,+int,+int,+int]))? - Time taken 0.00s] [:- modeh(100,play([+int,+int,+int,+int,+int]))? - Time taken 0.00s] [:- modeb(1,and(+int,+int,-int))? - Time taken 0.00s] [:- modeb(1,xor(+int,+int,-int))? - Time taken 0.00s] [Testing for contradictions] [No contradictions found] yes [:- [b]? - Time taken 0.00s] |- [Testing for contradictions] [No contradictions found] yes [:- [example/ex_sampleSize126.pl]? - Time taken 0.00s] |- [Generalising play([15,5,10]).] [Most specific clause is] play([A,B,C]) :- and(A,A,A), and(A,B,B), and(A,C,C), and(B,A, B), and(B,B,B), and(B,C,D), and(C,A,C), and(C,B,D), and(C, C,C), xor(A,A,D), xor(A,B,C), xor(A,C,B), xor(B,A,C), xor(B,B,D), xor(B,C,A), xor(C,A,B), xor(C,B,A), xor(C, C,D), and(A,D,D), and(B,D,D), and(C,D,D), and(D,A,D), and(D,B,D), and(D,C,D), and(D,D,D), xor(A,D,A), xor(B, D,B), xor(C,D,C), xor(D,A,A), xor(D,B,B), xor(D,C,C), xor(D,D,D). [C:-12,1,2,0 play([A,B,C]).] [1 explored search nodes] f=-0,p=6,n=6,h=0 [No compression] [Generalising play([2,2,5,5]).] [Most specific clause is] play([A,A,B,B]) :- and(A,A,A), and(A,B,C), and(B,A,C), and(B, B,B), xor(A,A,C), xor(A,B,D), xor(B,A,D), xor(B,B,C), and(A,C,C), and(A,D,A), and(B,C,C), and(B,D,B), and(C, A,C), and(C,B,C), and(C,C,C), and(C,D,C), and(D,A,A), and(D,B,B), and(D,C,C), and(D,D,D), xor(A,C,A), xor(A, D,B), xor(B,C,B), xor(B,D,A), xor(C,A,A), xor(C,B,B), xor(C,C,C), xor(C,D,D), xor(D,A,B), xor(D,B,A), xor(D, C,D), xor(D,D,C). [C:0,1,0,0 play([A,A,B,B]).] [C:0,1,0,0 play([A,A,B,C]).] [C:0,1,0,0 play([A,B,C,C]).] [C:0,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(B,A,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,B,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(B,B,B).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(B,B,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,D,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(B,C,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(B,D,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(C,A,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(D,A,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(C,B,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(D,B,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(C,C,C).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(C,C,E).] [C:-6,2,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(D,C,C).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(D,C,E).] [C:-6,2,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(C,D,C).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(C,D,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(D,D,D).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(D,D,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(B,A,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,B,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(B,B,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,D,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(B,C,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(B,D,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(C,A,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(D,A,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(C,B,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(D,B,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(C,C,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(D,C,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(C,D,E).] [C:-1,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(D,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(A,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(A,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(B,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(B,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(C,A,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(D,A,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(C,B,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(D,B,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(C,C,C).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(C,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(D,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(C,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(D,D,D).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(D,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(A,A,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(B,A,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(A,B,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(B,B,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(A,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(A,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(B,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(B,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(C,A,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(D,A,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(C,B,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(D,B,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(C,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(D,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(C,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,A,A), xor(D,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(C,A,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(C,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(D,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(C,B,F).] [C:2,4,0,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(D,B,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(D,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(C,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(D,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(C,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(D,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(A,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(B,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(C,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(D,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(E,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(E,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(E,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(E,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(E,E,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), and(E,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(A,E,C).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(A,E,F).] [C:2,4,0,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(B,E,D).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(B,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(C,E,A).] [C:2,4,0,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(D,E,B).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(C,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(D,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(E,A,C).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(E,A,F).] [C:2,4,0,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(E,B,D).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(E,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(E,C,A).] [C:2,4,0,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(E,D,B).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(E,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(E,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(E,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(A,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(A,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(B,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(B,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(C,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(D,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(C,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(D,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(C,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(C,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(D,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(C,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(D,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(D,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(A,E,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(A,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(B,E,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(B,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(C,E,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(C,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(D,E,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(D,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,A,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,B,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,C,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,D,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,E,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), and(E,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(A,E,A).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(A,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(B,E,B).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(B,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(C,E,C).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(C,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(D,E,D).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(D,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,A,A).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,B,B).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,C,C).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,D,D).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,E,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,A,E), xor(E,E,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(C,A,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(C,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(D,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(C,B,F).] [C:-2,3,1,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(D,B,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(D,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(C,C,C).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(C,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(D,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(C,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(D,D,D).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(D,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(A,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(B,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(A,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(B,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(A,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(A,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(B,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(B,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(C,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(D,A,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(C,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(D,B,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(C,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(D,C,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(C,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), xor(D,D,F).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(A,E,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(A,E,F).] [C:-1,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E).] [C:-3,4,3,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,F).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(C,E,E).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(C,E,F).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(D,E,E).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(D,E,F).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(E,A,E).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(E,A,F).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(E,B,E).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(E,B,F).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(E,C,E).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(E,C,F).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(E,D,E).] [C:-3,4,2,0 play([A,B,C,D]) :- and(A,C,E), and(B,E,E), and(E,D,F).] Resource limit exceeded [203 explored search nodes] f=2,p=4,n=0,h=0 [Result of search is] play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(D,B,E). [4 redundant clauses retracted] [Generalising play([1,13,12,7,7]).] [Most specific clause is] play([A,B,C,D,D]) :- and(A,A,A), and(A,B,A), and(A,C,E), and(A, D,A), and(B,A,A), and(B,B,B), and(B,C,C), and(B,D,F), and(C,A,E), and(C,B,C), and(C,C,C), and(C,D,G), and(D, A,A), and(D,B,F), and(D,C,G), and(D,D,D), xor(A,A,E), xor(A,B,C), xor(A,C,B), xor(A,D,H), xor(B,A,C), xor(B, B,E), xor(B,C,A), xor(B,D,I), xor(C,A,B), xor(C,B,A), xor(C,C,E), xor(C,D,J), xor(D,A,H), xor(D,B,I), xor(D, C,J), xor(D,D,E), and(A,E,E), and(A,G,E), and(A,F,A), and(A,H,E), and(A,J,A), and(A,I,E), and(B,E,E), and(B, G,G), and(B,F,F), and(B,H,G), and(B,J,K), and(B,I,L), and(C,E,E), and(C,G,G), and(C,F,G), and(C,H,G), and(C, J,L), and(C,I,L), and(D,E,E), and(D,G,G), and(D,F,F), and(D,H,H), and(D,J,M), and(D,I,N), and(E,A,E), and(E, B,E), and(E,C,E), and(E,D,E), and(E,E,E), and(E,G,E), and(E,F,E), and(E,H,E), and(E,J,E), and(E,I,E), and(G, A,E), and(G,B,G), and(G,C,G), and(G,D,G), and(G,E,E), and(G,G,G), and(G,F,G), and(G,H,G), and(G,J,E), and(G, I,E), and(F,A,A), and(F,B,F), and(F,C,G), and(F,D,F), and(F,E,E), and(F,G,G), and(F,F,F), and(F,H,G), and(F, J,A), and(F,I,E), and(H,A,E), and(H,B,G), and(H,C,G), and(H,D,H), and(H,E,E), and(H,G,G), and(H,F,G), and(H, H,H), and(H,J,N), and(H,I,N), and(J,A,A), and(J,B,K), and(J,C,L), and(J,D,M), and(J,E,E), and(J,G,E), and(J, F,A), and(J,H,N), and(J,J,J), and(J,I,I), and(I,A,E), and(I,B,L), and(I,C,L), and(I,D,N), and(I,E,E), and(I, G,E), and(I,F,E), and(I,H,N), and(I,J,I), and(I,I,I), xor(A,E,A), xor(A,G,F), xor(A,F,G), xor(A,H,D), xor(A, J,I), xor(A,I,J), xor(B,E,B), xor(B,G,K), xor(B,F,L), xor(B,H,J), xor(B,J,H), xor(B,I,D), xor(C,E,C), xor(C, G,L), xor(C,F,K), xor(C,H,I), xor(C,J,D), xor(C,I,H), xor(D,E,D), xor(D,G,M), xor(D,F,N), xor(D,H,A), xor(D, J,C), xor(D,I,B), xor(E,A,A), xor(E,B,B), xor(E,C,C), xor(E,D,D), xor(E,E,E), xor(E,G,G), xor(E,F,F), xor(E, H,H), xor(E,J,J), xor(E,I,I), xor(G,A,F), xor(G,B,K), xor(G,C,L), xor(G,D,M), xor(G,E,G), xor(G,G,E), xor(G, F,A), xor(G,H,N), xor(G,J,O), xor(G,I,P), xor(F,A,G), xor(F,B,L), xor(F,C,K), xor(F,D,N), xor(F,E,F), xor(F, G,A), xor(F,F,E), xor(F,H,M), xor(F,J,P), xor(F,I,O), xor(H,A,D), xor(H,B,J), xor(H,C,I), xor(H,D,A), xor(H, E,H), xor(H,G,N), xor(H,F,M), xor(H,H,E), xor(H,J,B), xor(H,I,C), xor(J,A,I), xor(J,B,H), xor(J,C,D), xor(J, D,C), xor(J,E,J), xor(J,G,O), xor(J,F,P), xor(J,H,B), xor(J,J,E), xor(J,I,A), xor(I,A,J), xor(I,B,D), xor(I, C,H), xor(I,D,B), xor(I,E,I), xor(I,G,P), xor(I,F,O), xor(I,H,C), xor(I,J,A), xor(I,I,E), and(A,N,E), and(A, L,E), and(A,M,A), and(A,K,A), and(A,P,E), and(A,O,A), and(B,N,E), and(B,L,L), and(B,M,A), and(B,K,K), and(B, P,C), and(B,O,B), and(C,N,E), and(C,L,L), and(C,M,E), and(C,K,L), and(C,P,C), and(C,O,C), and(D,N,N), and(D, L,E), and(D,M,M), and(D,K,A), and(D,P,H), and(D,O,D), and(E,N,E), and(E,L,E), and(E,M,E), and(E,K,E), and(E, P,E), and(E,O,E), and(G,N,E), and(G,L,E), and(G,M,E), and(G,K,E), and(G,P,G), and(G,O,G), and(F,N,E), and(F, L,E), and(F,M,A), and(F,K,A), and(F,P,G), and(F,O,F), and(H,N,N), and(H,L,E), and(H,M,N), and(H,K,E), and(H, P,H), and(H,O,H), and(J,N,N), and(J,L,L), and(J,M,M), and(J,K,K), and(J,P,I), and(J,O,J), and(I,N,N), and(I, L,L), and(I,M,N), and(I,K,L), and(I,P,I), and(I,O,I), and(N,A,E), and(N,B,E), and(N,C,E), and(N,D,N), and(N, E,E), and(N,G,E), and(N,F,E), and(N,H,N), and(N,J,N), and(N,I,N), and(N,N,N), and(N,L,E), and(N,M,N), and(N, K,E), and(N,P,N), and(N,O,N), and(L,A,E), and(L,B,L), and(L,C,L), and(L,D,E), and(L,E,E), and(L,G,E), and(L, F,E), and(L,H,E), and(L,J,L), and(L,I,L), and(L,N,E), and(L,L,L), and(L,M,E), and(L,K,L), and(L,P,L), and(L, O,L), and(M,A,A), and(M,B,A), and(M,C,E), and(M,D,M), and(M,E,E), and(M,G,E), and(M,F,A), and(M,H,N), and(M, J,M), and(M,I,N), and(M,N,N), and(M,L,E), and(M,M,M), and(M,K,A), and(M,P,N), and(M,O,M), and(K,A,A), and(K, B,K), and(K,C,L), and(K,D,A), and(K,E,E), and(K,G,E), and(K,F,A), and(K,H,E), and(K,J,K), and(K,I,L), and(K, N,E), and(K,L,L), and(K,M,A), and(K,K,K), and(K,P,L), and(K,O,K), and(P,A,E), and(P,B,C), and(P,C,C), and(P, D,H), and(P,E,E), and(P,G,G), and(P,F,G), and(P,H,H), and(P,J,I), and(P,I,I), and(P,N,N), and(P,L,L), and(P, M,N), and(P,K,L), and(P,P,P), and(P,O,P), and(O,A,A), and(O,B,B), and(O,C,C), and(O,D,D), and(O,E,E), and(O, G,G), and(O,F,F), and(O,H,H), and(O,J,J), and(O,I,I), and(O,N,N), and(O,L,L), and(O,M,M), and(O,K,K), and(O, P,P), and(O,O,O), xor(A,N,M), xor(A,L,K), xor(A,M,N), xor(A,K,L), xor(A,P,O), xor(A,O,P), xor(B,N,O), xor(B, L,F), xor(B,M,P), xor(B,K,G), xor(B,P,M), xor(B,O,N), xor(C,N,P), xor(C,L,G), xor(C,M,O), xor(C,K,F), xor(C, P,N), xor(C,O,M), xor(D,N,F), xor(D,L,O), xor(D,M,G), xor(D,K,P), xor(D,P,K), xor(D,O,L), xor(E,N,N), xor(E, L,L), xor(E,M,M), xor(E,K,K), xor(E,P,P), xor(E,O,O), xor(G,N,H), xor(G,L,C), xor(G,M,D), xor(G,K,B), xor(G, P,I), xor(G,O,J), xor(F,N,D), xor(F,L,B), xor(F,M,H), xor(F,K,C), xor(F,P,J), xor(F,O,I), xor(H,N,G), xor(H, L,P), xor(H,M,F), xor(H,K,O), xor(H,P,L), xor(H,O,K), xor(J,N,K), xor(J,L,M), xor(J,M,L), xor(J,K,N), xor(J, P,F), xor(J,O,G), xor(I,N,L), xor(I,L,N), xor(I,M,K), xor(I,K,M), xor(I,P,G), xor(I,O,F), xor(N,A,M), xor(N, B,O), xor(N,C,P), xor(N,D,F), xor(N,E,N), xor(N,G,H), xor(N,F,D), xor(N,H,G), xor(N,J,K), xor(N,I,L), xor(N, N,E), xor(N,L,I), xor(N,M,A), xor(N,K,J), xor(N,P,C), xor(N,O,B), xor(L,A,K), xor(L,B,F), xor(L,C,G), xor(L, D,O), xor(L,E,L), xor(L,G,C), xor(L,F,B), xor(L,H,P), xor(L,J,M), xor(L,I,N), xor(L,N,I), xor(L,L,E), xor(L, M,J), xor(L,K,A), xor(L,P,H), xor(L,O,D), xor(M,A,N), xor(M,B,P), xor(M,C,O), xor(M,D,G), xor(M,E,M), xor(M, G,D), xor(M,F,H), xor(M,H,F), xor(M,J,L), xor(M,I,K), xor(M,N,A), xor(M,L,J), xor(M,M,E), xor(M,K,I), xor(M, P,B), xor(M,O,C), xor(K,A,L), xor(K,B,G), xor(K,C,F), xor(K,D,P), xor(K,E,K), xor(K,G,B), xor(K,F,C), xor(K, H,O), xor(K,J,N), xor(K,I,M), xor(K,N,J), xor(K,L,A), xor(K,M,I), xor(K,K,E), xor(K,P,D), xor(K,O,H), xor(P, A,O), xor(P,B,M), xor(P,C,N), xor(P,D,K), xor(P,E,P), xor(P,G,I), xor(P,F,J), xor(P,H,L), xor(P,J,F), xor(P, I,G), xor(P,N,C), xor(P,L,H), xor(P,M,B), xor(P,K,D), xor(P,P,E), xor(P,O,A), xor(O,A,P), xor(O,B,N), xor(O, C,M), xor(O,D,L), xor(O,E,O), xor(O,G,J), xor(O,F,I), xor(O,H,K), xor(O,J,G), xor(O,I,F), xor(O,N,B), xor(O, L,D), xor(O,M,C), xor(O,K,H), xor(O,P,A), xor(O,O,E). [C:0,1,0,0 play([A,B,C,D,D]).] [C:-6,1,1,0 play([A,B,C,D,E]).] [2 explored search nodes] f=0,p=1,n=0,h=0 [Result of search is] play([A,B,C,D,D]). [1 redundant clauses retracted] play([15,5,10]). play([A,B,C,D]) :- xor(A,C,E), xor(D,B,E). play([A,B,C,D,D]). [Total number of clauses = 3] yes [:- generalise(play/1)? - Time taken 0.23s] |- [False negative:]play([1,3,2]). [False negative:]play([1,4,5]). [False negative:]play([1,5,4]). [False negative:]play([1,6,7]). [False negative:]play([1,7,6]). [False negative:]play([1,8,9]). [False negative:]play([1,9,8]). [False negative:]play([1,10,11]). [False negative:]play([1,11,10]). [False negative:]play([1,13,12]). [False negative:]play([2,1,3]). [False negative:]play([2,3,1]). [False negative:]play([2,4,6]). [False negative:]play([2,6,4]). [False negative:]play([2,7,5]). [False negative:]play([2,8,10]). [False negative:]play([2,10,8]). [False negative:]play([2,11,9]). [False negative:]play([2,12,14]). [False negative:]play([2,13,15]). [False negative:]play([2,14,12]). [False negative:]play([3,1,2]). [False negative:]play([3,2,1]). [False negative:]play([3,4,7]). [False negative:]play([3,5,6]). [False negative:]play([3,6,5]). [False negative:]play([3,7,4]). [False negative:]play([3,8,11]). [False negative:]play([3,9,10]). [False negative:]play([3,13,14]). [False negative:]play([3,14,13]). [False negative:]play([3,15,12]). [False negative:]play([4,1,5]). [False negative:]play([4,2,6]). [False negative:]play([4,3,7]). [False negative:]play([4,5,1]). [False negative:]play([4,6,2]). [False negative:]play([4,7,3]). [False negative:]play([4,8,12]). [False negative:]play([4,11,15]). [False negative:]play([4,12,8]). [False negative:]play([4,13,9]). [False negative:]play([4,14,10]). [False negative:]play([4,15,11]). [False negative:]play([5,1,4]). [False negative:]play([5,2,7]). [False negative:]play([5,3,6]). [False negative:]play([5,4,1]). [False negative:]play([5,6,3]). [False negative:]play([5,7,2]). [False negative:]play([5,8,13]). [False negative:]play([5,10,15]). [False negative:]play([5,11,14]). [False negative:]play([5,12,9]). [False negative:]play([5,13,8]). [False negative:]play([5,14,11]). [False negative:]play([5,15,10]). [False negative:]play([6,2,4]). [False negative:]play([6,3,5]). [False negative:]play([6,4,2]). [False negative:]play([6,5,3]). [False negative:]play([6,8,14]). [False negative:]play([6,9,15]). [False negative:]play([6,10,12]). [False negative:]play([6,11,13]). [False negative:]play([6,12,10]). [False negative:]play([6,13,11]). [False negative:]play([6,14,8]). [False negative:]play([6,15,9]). [False negative:]play([7,1,6]). [False negative:]play([7,2,5]). [False negative:]play([7,3,4]). [False negative:]play([7,5,2]). [False negative:]play([7,9,14]). [False negative:]play([7,12,11]). [False negative:]play([7,13,10]). [False negative:]play([7,14,9]). [False negative:]play([7,15,8]). [False negative:]play([8,1,9]). [False negative:]play([8,3,11]). [False negative:]play([8,4,12]). [False negative:]play([8,5,13]). [False negative:]play([8,6,14]). [False negative:]play([8,7,15]). [False negative:]play([8,9,1]). [False negative:]play([8,10,2]). [False negative:]play([8,11,3]). [False negative:]play([8,12,4]). [False negative:]play([8,13,5]). [False negative:]play([8,14,6]). [False negative:]play([8,15,7]). [False negative:]play([9,1,8]). [False negative:]play([9,2,11]). [False negative:]play([9,3,10]). [False negative:]play([9,4,13]). [False negative:]play([9,5,12]). [False negative:]play([9,6,15]). [False negative:]play([9,8,1]). [False negative:]play([9,10,3]). [False negative:]play([9,11,2]). [False negative:]play([9,12,5]). [False negative:]play([9,14,7]). [False negative:]play([10,1,11]). [False negative:]play([10,2,8]). [False negative:]play([10,4,14]). [False negative:]play([10,5,15]). [False negative:]play([10,6,12]). [False negative:]play([10,8,2]). [False negative:]play([10,9,3]). [False negative:]play([10,11,1]). [False negative:]play([10,12,6]). [False negative:]play([10,13,7]). [False negative:]play([10,14,4]). [False negative:]play([10,15,5]). [False negative:]play([11,1,10]). [False negative:]play([11,2,9]). [False negative:]play([11,3,8]). [False negative:]play([11,4,15]). [False negative:]play([11,5,14]). [False negative:]play([11,6,13]). [False negative:]play([11,7,12]). [False negative:]play([11,8,3]). [False negative:]play([11,9,2]). [False negative:]play([11,10,1]). [False negative:]play([11,12,7]). [False negative:]play([11,13,6]). [False negative:]play([11,14,5]). [False negative:]play([11,15,4]). [False negative:]play([12,1,13]). [False negative:]play([12,2,14]). [False negative:]play([12,4,8]). [False negative:]play([12,5,9]). [False negative:]play([12,6,10]). [False negative:]play([12,7,11]). [False negative:]play([12,8,4]). [False negative:]play([12,9,5]). [False negative:]play([12,10,6]). [False negative:]play([12,13,1]). [False negative:]play([12,14,2]). [False negative:]play([12,15,3]). [False negative:]play([13,1,12]). [False negative:]play([13,4,9]). [False negative:]play([13,5,8]). [False negative:]play([13,6,11]). [False negative:]play([13,7,10]). [False negative:]play([13,8,5]). [False negative:]play([13,9,4]). [False negative:]play([13,10,7]). [False negative:]play([13,12,1]). [False negative:]play([13,15,2]). [False negative:]play([14,1,15]). [False negative:]play([14,2,12]). [False negative:]play([14,3,13]). [False negative:]play([14,5,11]). [False negative:]play([14,6,8]). [False negative:]play([14,7,9]). [False negative:]play([14,8,6]). [False negative:]play([14,9,7]). [False negative:]play([14,10,4]). [False negative:]play([14,11,5]). [False negative:]play([14,12,2]). [False negative:]play([14,13,3]). [False negative:]play([14,15,1]). [False negative:]play([15,1,14]). [False negative:]play([15,3,12]). [False negative:]play([15,4,11]). [False negative:]play([15,6,9]). [False negative:]play([15,7,8]). [False negative:]play([15,8,7]). [False negative:]play([15,10,5]). [False negative:]play([15,11,4]). [False negative:]play([15,13,2]). [False negative:]play([15,14,1]). [False negative:]play([1,2,12,1,14]). [False negative:]play([1,6,6,3,2]). [False negative:]play([1,7,7,14,15]). [False negative:]play([1,8,12,13,8]). [False negative:]play([1,9,4,11,7]). [False negative:]play([1,9,14,10,12]). [False negative:]play([1,11,4,6,8]). [False negative:]play([1,15,4,15,5]). [False negative:]play([2,1,4,6,1]). [False negative:]play([2,1,12,10,5]). [False negative:]play([2,2,6,12,10]). [False negative:]play([2,3,3,9,11]). [False negative:]play([2,3,9,2,10]). [False negative:]play([2,5,13,8,2]). [False negative:]play([2,6,10,11,5]). [False negative:]play([2,8,3,15,6]). [False negative:]play([2,8,4,7,9]). [False negative:]play([2,9,5,10,4]). [False negative:]play([2,9,13,3,5]). [False negative:]play([2,13,12,10,9]). [False negative:]play([2,14,2,12,2]). [False negative:]play([2,14,9,15,10]). [False negative:]play([3,2,3,11,9]). [False negative:]play([3,2,15,5,11]). [False negative:]play([3,3,1,2,3]). [False negative:]play([3,5,15,4,13]). [False negative:]play([3,8,4,6,9]). [False negative:]play([3,9,7,8,5]). [False negative:]play([3,11,2,7,13]). [False negative:]play([3,14,7,6,12]). [False negative:]play([3,15,10,2,4]). [False negative:]play([4,1,15,3,9]). [False negative:]play([4,3,5,15,13]). [False negative:]play([4,3,10,9,4]). [False negative:]play([4,4,12,13,1]). [False negative:]play([4,9,7,6,12]). [False negative:]play([4,9,14,5,6]). [False negative:]play([4,12,4,2,14]). [False negative:]play([4,12,9,7,6]). [False negative:]play([4,13,14,8,15]). [False negative:]play([4,14,1,12,7]). [False negative:]play([5,7,5,1,6]). [False negative:]play([5,7,13,1,14]). [False negative:]play([5,8,11,7,1]). [False negative:]play([5,9,15,2,1]). [False negative:]play([5,10,5,8,2]). [False negative:]play([5,10,7,1,9]). [False negative:]play([5,11,8,1,7]). [False negative:]play([5,11,11,4,1]). [False negative:]play([5,11,11,12,9]). [False negative:]play([5,13,6,7,9]). [False negative:]play([5,15,5,13,2]). [False negative:]play([6,1,13,15,5]). [False negative:]play([6,2,9,14,3]). [False negative:]play([6,5,15,2,14]). [False negative:]play([6,6,6,4,2]). [False negative:]play([6,7,3,6,4]). [False negative:]play([6,7,11,13,7]). [False negative:]play([6,11,3,11,5]). [False negative:]play([6,15,12,11,14]). [False negative:]play([7,2,1,12,8]). [False negative:]play([7,2,10,14,1]). [False negative:]play([7,2,14,2,9]). [False negative:]play([7,5,11,12,5]). [False negative:]play([7,6,7,11,13]). [False negative:]play([7,7,9,3,10]). [False negative:]play([7,8,12,15,12]). [False negative:]play([7,9,2,2,14]). [False negative:]play([7,10,6,4,15]). [False negative:]play([7,10,8,2,7]). [False negative:]play([7,13,3,15,6]). [False negative:]play([7,14,8,13,12]). [False negative:]play([7,14,15,5,3]). [False negative:]play([8,1,2,9,2]). [False negative:]play([8,4,11,12,11]). [False negative:]play([8,5,9,12,8]). [False negative:]play([8,8,10,1,11]). [False negative:]play([8,9,8,12,5]). [False negative:]play([8,10,12,7,9]). [False negative:]play([8,11,1,13,15]). [False negative:]play([9,2,9,8,10]). [False negative:]play([9,6,9,4,2]). [False negative:]play([9,8,14,14,1]). [False negative:]play([9,10,11,5,13]). [False negative:]play([9,12,6,7,4]). [False negative:]play([9,12,15,14,4]). [False negative:]play([9,15,11,6,11]). [False negative:]play([10,1,4,12,3]). [False negative:]play([10,3,2,15,4]). [False negative:]play([10,3,3,4,14]). [False negative:]play([10,3,7,1,15]). [False negative:]play([10,4,10,9,13]). [False negative:]play([10,6,2,11,5]). [False negative:]play([10,7,2,3,12]). [False negative:]play([10,9,1,5,7]). [False negative:]play([10,10,8,1,9]). [False negative:]play([10,11,5,13,9]). [False negative:]play([10,11,12,11,6]). [False negative:]play([10,11,14,11,4]). [False negative:]play([10,13,11,2,14]). [False negative:]play([10,14,8,9,5]). [False negative:]play([10,14,12,10,2]). [False negative:]play([10,15,12,2,11]). [False negative:]play([11,1,15,6,3]). [False negative:]play([11,4,5,7,13]). [False negative:]play([11,4,7,11,3]). [False negative:]play([11,6,7,3,9]). [False negative:]play([11,6,14,8,11]). [False negative:]play([11,7,6,12,6]). [False negative:]play([11,8,2,9,8]). [False negative:]play([11,8,4,15,8]). [False negative:]play([11,8,7,10,14]). [False negative:]play([11,8,10,13,4]). [False negative:]play([11,11,13,15,2]). [False negative:]play([11,13,14,7,15]). [False negative:]play([11,15,7,8,11]). [False negative:]play([12,1,6,5,14]). [False negative:]play([12,5,6,6,9]). [False negative:]play([12,6,4,4,10]). [False negative:]play([12,7,6,1,12]). [False negative:]play([12,8,11,4,11]). [False negative:]play([12,11,10,5,8]). [False negative:]play([12,11,15,4,12]). [False negative:]play([12,13,15,6,8]). [False negative:]play([12,14,11,7,14]). [False negative:]play([13,3,1,5,10]). [False negative:]play([13,3,4,3,9]). [False negative:]play([13,3,4,7,13]). [False negative:]play([13,3,5,4,15]). [False negative:]play([13,3,11,7,2]). [False negative:]play([13,4,3,15,5]). [False negative:]play([13,4,5,9,5]). [False negative:]play([13,4,11,1,3]). [False negative:]play([13,7,8,14,12]). [False negative:]play([13,9,1,13,8]). [False negative:]play([13,11,13,7,12]). [False negative:]play([13,11,14,13,5]). [False negative:]play([13,12,8,6,15]). [False negative:]play([13,12,15,1,15]). [False negative:]play([13,13,15,1,14]). [False negative:]play([13,15,4,2,4]). [False negative:]play([14,1,8,6,1]). [False negative:]play([14,6,14,15,9]). [False negative:]play([14,8,4,3,1]). [False negative:]play([14,8,12,9,3]). [False negative:]play([14,9,11,15,3]). [False negative:]play([14,10,14,9,3]). [False negative:]play([14,11,14,10,1]). [False negative:]play([14,14,8,9,1]). [False negative:]play([15,3,6,14,4]). [False negative:]play([15,4,1,13,7]). [False negative:]play([15,5,7,1,12]). [False negative:]play([15,10,8,15,2]). [False negative:]play([15,13,7,3,6]). [False negative:]play([15,14,12,15,2]). [False positive:]:- play([1,7,10,6,6]). [False positive:]:- play([1,9,4,2,2]). [False positive:]:- play([1,9,12,7,7]). [False positive:]:- play([2,1,10,5,5]). [False positive:]:- play([3,7,11,1,1]). [False positive:]:- play([4,5,4,10,10]). [False positive:]:- play([5,12,15,3,3]). [False positive:]:- play([7,2,1,10,10]). [False positive:]:- play([7,2,6,11,11]). [False positive:]:- play([7,5,7,12,12]). [False positive:]:- play([8,13,3,2,2]). [False positive:]:- play([10,5,14,15,15]). [False positive:]:- play([10,7,5,14,14]). [False positive:]:- play([11,10,13,6,6]). [False positive:]:- play([14,12,4,3,3]). [PREDICATE play/1] Contingency table= ________A________~A P| 172| 15| 187 |( 93.5)|( 93.5)| ~P| 328| 485| 813 |( 406.5)|( 406.5)| ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 500 500 1000 [Overall accuracy= 65.70% +/- 1.50%] [Chi-square = 160.07] [Without Yates correction = 162.13] [Chi-square probability = 0.0000] yes [:- test(test_1000)? - Time taken 0.01s] |-